When Jimmy Allen opened the letter with his freshman year housing assignment and saw McCollum Hall, it wasn't long before he had requested to be switched to Templin Hall.
"I wanted an environment I could study in," said
Allen,
Only three residence halls for traditional students had a grade point average over a 3.0 for the fall 2008 semester: Corbin Hall with 3.03, Templin with 3.36 and the scholarship halls with 3.37. The fall 2008 GPA for the entire freshmen class was 2.635.
This bar graph shows the different GPAs among the residence halls on campus from the fall of 2008.
Templin and the scholarship halls have certain criteria for the students admitted to live there. Templin requires residents to maintain a 3.25 grade point average. Students interested in the scholarship halls prepare an additional application with essays and recommendation letters.
The Department of Student Housing said that putting these students together does put them at an advantage for grades.
"If you've got a group of folks that have been brought together as scholars, chances are that's probably going to be a more scholarly environment just by the nature of their individual interests and backgrounds," Diana Robertson said.
Robertson is the director of student housing. She said that the smaller populations of Templin and the scholarship halls also help raise the average. Templin has 277 students and the 11 scholarship halls each have about 50 students living in each.
Lewis Hall, located on Daisy Hill with Templin, has fewer residents than Templin with a population of 272. Lewis also has a lower GPA of 2.85.
"Another thing that's interesting about Templin is that people keep to themselves and are very quiet," Stephanie Jian said. "It's a pretty insular community."
Jian,
"My experience just going to dorms like McCollum is that you meet people a lot more openly just because everyone is really close together," Jian said. "Your doors are open you see your neighbors all the time."
Located on Daisy Hill, McCollum Hall has the lowest GPA, 2.38, and the highest population, 887, of the residence halls.
Allen said he heard it had a reputation for being cramped, loud and a place for students without academic motivation.
"I didn't really want that," he said. "[Templin] is a good study environment and just seems to attract the best students."
Jian said the choice between the academic and social environment is difficult for any student. Being social could be fun, but it could also be a distraction.
Templin definitely veers away from distraction. Jian didn't see her neighbors from across the hall until this April
"I think there's a trade-off," she said. "If you want to be more social it would be good for you to be at McCollum."
Robertson said students with academic scholarships or in the honors program are given priority consideration for Templin.
The honors program does tip off its participants to what is offered at Templin and the scholarship halls. Mark Daly, associate director for the honors program, also said it's important for freshmen to find something other than a roof over their heads plus the meal plan.
"But we do definitely bring up the scholarship halls are there and what they have to offer," Daly said. "Or Templin with the GPA component."
Daly said that at one time the scholarship hall population was nearly 60% honors students, but is unsure what the numbers are now.
Kelsie Lange has lived in Hashinger Hall, McCollum and Watkins Scholarship Hall. She sees a palpable difference between the type of students in the scholarship halls and residence halls.
"[The scholarship
halls] are more geared toward motivated students, seeing as you have to write
essays and get recommendations to get accepted," the
Robertson said that it's difficult to control the environment in residence halls. The size and the variance of students create an unpredictable dynamic that changes floor to floor and hall to hall.
"Some students begin to find where they live to be the place that they can study; others don't study in that environment," Robertson said.
The Department of
Student Housing placed
"We want to balance [academics] with the residence halls being the place students where students can come to relax, unwind," Robertson said. "It is their home."
The scholarship halls tout community living as one of their unique features. This community feeling is because of their smaller population and one of the distinctions scholarship halls have from the residence halls.
"I think it's harder to just drop off the face of the earth in the scholarship halls than it is in the dorms, especially somewhere like McCollum where you could just be one of a hundred," Paul Spacek said.
Spacek,
"I think some people have that stigma about honors dorms, that people think they're better," he said.
Daly said he saw this reputation also but that for students with higher academic standards opportunities like the scholarship halls and Templin are good to have available.
With such diverse students, diverse in the sense of level of preparedness and level of motivation, he said, different niches are necessary.
"I think it's good that there is a place or a few buildings where students who really want to be able to take their studies a little more seriously than the average student at KU can go," Daly said.
Robertson said that the scholarship halls and Templin generally have more requests than space allows but don't keep records of the exact numbers of students turned away.
Daly said this "theme-based housing" may create groups among residents, but that is just part of human nature.
Allen appreciated that aspect of Templin. Living there his freshman year was good for his grades.
"Those who are more scholarly or academically-geared end up living there," he said.
