Erin knew she was in trouble as soon as she saw the police officers walk into the bar. Erin, a Topeka sophomore who asked that her last name be omitted, was one of five underage girls drinking at Fatso's, 1016 Massachusetts Street, when two police officers asked for their identification.
Erin was using the ID of a woman three years older and 50 pounds heavier. Her ID also said she was 5 feet 1 inch tall, though she is actually 5 feet 3 inches. The police collected IDs from all of the girls and returned them to every girl except Erin. One of the officers began to quiz Erin over the information on her ID.
Erin, left, uses the ID of a woman, right, who is two inches shorter and fifty pounds heavier.
Photos by Abbey Strusz
"He told me to stand up, so I stand up and I'm taller than the cop," Erin said. "You know, I'm like 5'8, because I'm really 5'3 and I have these heels on. So I'm just so much taller than he is. But he gave me my ID back and that was that."
Erin was one of many underage drinkers in Lawrence who con their way into bars using fake IDs or the IDs of older people.
Last year Lawrence charged 123 people with using fake IDs or the wrong ID, said Vicki Stanwix, Lawrence Court Administrator. Only eight of these cases were not alcohol related. This year 18 people have been charged, and only one charge was not related to alcohol, Stanwix said.
Minors who use false identification to obtain alcohol face legal consequences. The minor is usually charged with unlawful use of a driver's license or non-driver's identification card, said Karen Price, an Alcohol Beverage Control Enforcement Agent.
Price said the violation is a misdemeanor offense, and can vary in penalties from 100 hours of public service to a fine of up to $2500 or
confinement in jail for up to one year.
Erin describes a close call she had with the police while using false identification.
Erin got away with her offense. Sarah, Topeka junior who also asked her last name be omitted, was not so lucky.
Sarah and some work friends were at Wilde's Chateau 24, 2412 Iowa Street, when she was removed from the bar and written up for using false identification.
"I'd maybe been there for like 10 minutes when the police came up to me," Sarah said. "It makes me think maybe the manager pointed me out, but I don't know why he would do that, because he'd get in trouble too."
Charles Mee, one of the owners of the Chateau, said employees would not point underage drinkers out to the police because they don't let minors in on purpose. Bars caught serving underage drinkers face severe consequences, from fines to suspension days to losing their liquor licenses.
Dave Boulter, co-owner of the Chateau, said most patrons use driver's licenses as identification. Before someone enters the bar, the door worker checks the license with a black light to see the holograms embedded in licenses. Boulter said this is the best test to see if an ID is real because the holograms are hard to fake. He said his door workers had the most trouble with IDs that are real but do not belong to the people trying to use them.
Door workers at Wilde's Chateau 24 complete a checklist for each ID they check. Information courtesy of Dave Boulter.
Graphic by Abbey Strusz
"You're not really getting the exact picture of the person, especially when you're 20, you're 21, you're 22. You change," Boulter said. "You can change in a summer. You can lose weight, gain weight, change your hair. It depends on so many things."
Erin said she had never been questioned before the time at Fatso's.
"I've used blonde girls' IDs before," Erin said. "I've used IDs that say I'm 28."
The Chateau also takes a picture of the ID and a picture of the person using it as a defense against possible charges. Boulter said this was especially useful when the wrong person uses a real ID.
"So I look at it, and I look at your height and weight, the color of your eyes and things like that," Boulter said. "If it looks reasonably good, and a normal person would say, 'yeah, that's you,' and we have a picture of it, it's a defense."
Price said one of the best ways for bars owners to protect themselves is to make sure their employees are checking the IDs properly.
"[Businesses can] support employees and encourage them to slow down, take their time, and get it right the first time, regardless of how long they may be 'holding up the line' or 'inconveniencing' a customer," Price said.
Erin said she gets away with her fake IDs at some places because she knows a door worker, but that a lot of her success has to do with the attitude she takes.
"I think it has to do with just being confident when you use it," Erin said. "If you act like you're scared, and you act unsure, they're going to know. They can tell. But if you act confident like, 'Yeah, this is me. Go ahead and question me about it. Are you saying this isn't me?' They're not going to question you."
