Anti-video game legislation worries retailers
Dan Hoyt | May 15, 2006 01:15 PM | Link
By Dan Hoyt
Many state legislatures across the nation are pushing to have laws banning the sale of violent video games to kids. While this may seem like a good idea the particulars of the laws themselves make it more of a problem than a solution.
Many of the laws make no mention of the Electronic Software Ratings Board which rates video games for content on the lines of movies and gives each video game a rating to be printed on the box.
“I’m not arguing that video games aren’t violent,” said Brian Harris owner of Game Guy, 7 E. Seventh Street, “I’ just saying that it’s unnecessary.”

Many college students play video games that are considered Mature rated like Grand Theft Auto.
Many major retail stores that sell video games already have policies in effect banning the sale of “Mature” rated games to minors. So while creating laws to enforce these policies may sound like a good idea Harris disagrees.
“Once you have decided to enforce these laws then what?,” Harris said. “Do you hire somebody and give him a staff? Then you have to give him funding why spend the money fixing a problem that has already been taken care of.”
Harris said in his position he is afraid that the government, either federal or state may follow California’s example and push vague and arbitrary laws through and try to enforce them.
The laws may be good intentioned, but without taking any of the ESRB guidelines it would be very difficult to decide what games are considered violent and shouldn’t be sold to minors. The law makes no mention of the ESRB ratings system and even though it defines “violent acts” it makes little distinction between graphic violence and cartoon violence.
Harris said the answer is in parental supervision. He doesn’t sell “M” rated games to kids without their permission and parents still buy the games for their kids. Even if laws were enacted it wouldn’t change anything. It would just create problems and cost money.
“I usually help parents make a good decision about the games their kids can play,” he said. “I want them to know what the content of the game is. I want them to be able to make an informed decision. Some parents care and that’s good and some don’t and I wish they would.
Many parents are confused by the ratings system at first, but once it’s explained they seem to understand. Harris said he wants to sell games, but he feels he needs to be responsible and let parents know what they’re getting into.
“I usually point out things like what the game has the ratings for. Sometimes it gets a “T” (Teen) rating for something small like the lyrics of some of the songs,” he said.
He believes that sometimes the ratings system is a little too harsh, but overall he said he believes it is a fairly accurate depiction of the content of the game. He said he wished movies were as accurate sometimes.
The problem is already fixing itself said Harris since Wal-Mart has become such a huge retailer and it refuses to sell “Adults Only” rated games so game developers strive to make sure they don’t get that rating.
David Smith, Overland Park sophomore, has been playing video games for many years and he agrees with what Harris said.
“The people that want to push that legislation are just reactionaries,” said Smith. “They are overeating to things like Columbine, sure those kids played Doom, but John Hinckley, Jr. attributed ‘The Catcher and the Rye’ and Jodie Foster for trying to kill Ronald Reagan.’
Smith said that he has played games like Grand Theft Auto and Halo and he doesn’t want to kill anybody or steal anything.
“That’s not my thing,” he said.
Smith pointed out that anti-videogame advocate Jack Thompson said the Beltway Sniper attacks were caused by someone who trained on “killing simulators” like Halo. After the killers were caught it was proven that none of that was true.
Smith said he is a good sniper in Halo, but doesn’t think e could do any real sniping considering on the few occasions he has shot a real gun he found to be a terrible shot.
“How would that teach me to shoot? I can’t use a gun,” Smith said. “I don’t know how to load a gun. I can’t even shoot little clay pigeons with a shotgun and I’m real good and first-person shooters.”
Smith said that the concept of blaming something for corrupting the media isn’t a new idea. People accused Socrates of corrupting the media.
“They should come up with a law banning Socrates. That might be more efficient,” Smith said.

Boog in his bedroom study. He has lived in a cooperative homes for most of his time in Lawrence.
Dan Kozak's rommates. Brenda Frankenfeld (center), Strully (left), and Cyprus (right).
Boog has an extensive collection of fan mail from his time as mayor.
Does eating meat aid in global warming? Researchers from the University of Chicago say so. photo from macveg.com
Vegetarian Food Pyramid. photo from www.westbrae.com
A gateway security system at Watson Library checks people.
There are two types of the tattle tape. Green one is used for peperback books, and white one is used for hardback books.
Many new and old books that have not tattle-taped pile up on a desk at Watson Library.
The Kansas rowing team practices on the Kansas River Saturday. With the $20 fee increase for women's and non-revenue sports, the team is expecting a new boathouse in the next three years.
These are the expenses and revenues for all the Big 12 schools during the 2004-05 school year. (source: Department of Education)
Most phones that are currently being sold are compatible for text messaging. Most providers are selling phone plans that include text messaging packages. However, going over your alotted texts costs ten cents for every extra text message.